Talks about otome games, drama cds, and occasionally provides advice? Running away endlessly from my backlog of hobbies.

Ilinox

Evan's writers, hands down without hesitation and without a doubt LOL. Regardless of whether it's his main writers or backup writers, his cards are almost always gorgeously written, well-paced, and have thought-provoking themes.

His writers are so strong they've proved that, in the face of absolute skill, people can only acknowledge it, whether you bias him, you dislike him, or you're even an outsider with no knowledge of the game and only seeing a snippet of writing. I swear I'm not exaggerating that their skill is to the point where, if someone dislikes the writing in his cards, that person can be said to have no reading or media comprehension LOL.

I'm someone who hesitates to put people on a pedestal, so I was always worried to jump on board the "It's Evan's writers—" train at the beginning of the 2nd year, because the higher expectations you have the greater your disappointment if they're not met, but after all these years there's really nothing to say but "It's Evan's writers—" whenever anything comes out for him, haha.

If I were to personally rank the men in terms of the writing skill and consistency of their cards then:

EvanSariel = OsbornCharlieJesse 

Osborn would rank lower for people if they don't like the themes in his cards because he's quite straightforward, but his writers have been very consistent in terms of quality. Meanwhile, Sariel has interesting themes but the quality in his cards vary more than Osborn and Evan's cards.

The quality in Charlie's cards shoots up and down.

Jesse's cards are consistent in their quality, but the problem is that they're generally kind of... average (I'll admit I'm prejudiced against his themes, but in my opinion his writers repeat the same relationship themes too much). If we set aside relationship cards, the writing in Jesse's chapter and AU cards are crazy good and he would shoot to being second place or equal with Evan's cards in terms of quality.

Evan's writers, hands down without hesitation and without a doubt LOL. Regardless of whether it's his main writers or backup writers, his cards are almost always gorgeously written, well-paced, and have thought-provoking themes.

His writers are so strong they've proved that, in the face of absolute skill, people can only acknowledge it, whether you bias him, you dislike him, or you're even an outsider with no knowledge of the game and only seeing a snippet of writing. I swear I'm not exaggerating that their skill is to the point where, if someone dislikes the writing in his cards, that person can be said to have no reading or media comprehension LOL.

I'm someone who hesitates to put people on a pedestal, so I was always worried to jump on board the "It's Evan's writers—" train at the beginning of the 2nd year, because the higher expectations you have the greater your disappointment if they're not met, but after all these years there's really nothing to say but "It's Evan's writers—" whenever anything comes out for him, haha.

If I were to personally rank the men in terms of the writing skill and consistency of their cards then:

Osborn would rank lower for people if they don't like the themes in his cards because he's quite straightforward, but his writers have been very consistent in terms of quality. Meanwhile, Sariel has interesting themes but the quality in his cards vary more than Osborn and Evan's cards.

The quality in Charlie's cards shoots up and down.

Jesse's cards are consistent in their quality, but the problem is that they're generally kind of... average (I'll admit I'm prejudiced against his themes, but in my opinion his writers repeat the same relationship themes too much). If we set aside relationship cards, the writing in Jesse's chapter and AU cards are crazy good and he would shoot to being second place or equal with Evan's cards in terms of quality.

Hi Ili, I want to ask your personal opinion about LN story writing. I'm sure no writer is perfect, regardless of the strengths and weaknesses of the stories so far, which LI's story writer do you think is the most consistent in terms of quality? It doesn't have to be perfect, but at least most of the story writing for LI can still be considered good and acceptable. It could also be from how much you are impressed by the style of the story telling which is beyond expectations or the writing which can touch your heart. Please don't get me wrong, I love every LI's in LN, but since I still use machine translation (aside from looking at your  thread) I still feel like I'm missing something so I'm afraid the writer intentions and story quality not reach me perfectly :"

Ilinox

Want to ask your personal opinion about LN story writing, especially for every LI's